Blue Shield of California has announced a rate increase effective March 1, 2011. Rate changes for most plans will average 15%, although the amount of your rate increase will depend on your age, gender, the plan you have, and the area you live in.
Why is this happening, and why is Blue Shield not deferring this rate increase as requested by Dave Jones, California Insurance Commissioner?
First, let’s give you some background on the way rate increases have been handled in the past. Typically, California health insurers have increased rates once a year, with Blue Cross raising rates in March and Blue Shield raising rates in July. These are the “trend increases,” or what you would call increases for medical inflation, new technology, and increased utilization. You may also receive a rate increase based on your migrating from one age category to another. So, for example, if you turn 50 in March, you could see a rate increase in April in addition to the annual rate increase that would happen in July.
Second, let’s review what happened last year in regards to California insurers. As you may recall, Anthem Blue Cross was in the news in early 2010, due to a large rate increase, which was as high as 59% for some plans. In fact, many attribute the successful passage of the Patient Affordability Act (PPACA) as backlash to the furor over this rate increase. Blue Cross was asked to defer their rate increase for 60 days while an independent actuary reviewed the statistics. They found that there were indeed some errors in their calculations, and they revised their rate increase accordingly. Their rate increase was deferred from March until it went into effect on September 23, 2010.
Because of this, Blue Shield proactively engaged independent actuaries in the summer, and they deferred their July rate increase until October 1, 2010. So—the rate increase which should have happened in July happened in October. Then, there was another rate “adjustment” in January, which was intended to make all plans gender-neutral. This adjustment was required by Health Care Reform, as beginning January 1st, health insurers could no longer charge more for females than males. In many cases, premiums went down, depending on your age and gender.
Now, Blue Shield is requesting another rate increase, to go into effect March 1, 2011. The California Insurance Commissioner has requested a 60-day delay, but Blue Shield is adamant in its intent to move forward with the rate increase. This tells me that they not only feel that it is necessary, but that they have thoroughly reviewed their statistics and have concluded that it is justified.
You may be asking yourself, “Didn’t Health Care Reform promise that health insurance costs would go down?” There’s been a whole lot of debate over that issue. I can tell you, after reading the entire bill this past summer, that I found little in the bill that would decrease health care costs. Theoretically, just increasing the number of people insured could have a dampening effect on medical inflation, as those insured would not have to subsidize the uninsured. But there’s little in the bill that would decrease the cost. Instead, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) primarily increases access and ensures quality. Here’s a blurb just this last week about the cost of health care—
WASHINGTON (AP) — Two of the central promises of President Barack Obama’s health care overhaul law are unlikely to be fulfilled, Medicare’s independent economic expert told Congress on Wednesday.
The landmark legislation probably won’t hold costs down, and it won’t let everybody keep their current health insurance if they like it, Chief Actuary Richard Foster told the House Budget Committee. His office is responsible for independent long-range cost estimates.
So—that brings us back to the present rate increase looming just ahead. Are there still ways to manage rate increases? Should I change plans? Are you still there to help?
Yes, we’re here to help you manage your rate increase and help you decide what to do. Our mission continues to be to help you get the most out of your health care dollars. We’re committed to doing that! Let’s break it down for you—
1. Are you still in the optimal plan? As a rule of thumb, you could benefit by changing plans every two to three years. So, if you haven’t changed plans in the last couple of years, let’s look at doing that. We might move you to a more economical plan in the same company. Sometimes, we can do that without significantly cutting your benefits. Or, we might consider moving you to a different company. Keep in mind, though, that any changes you make might be temporary, as the new plan or new company might have another rate increase shortly.
2. Do you qualify for state programs, such as Healthy Families, for your children? For a complete explanation of the Healthy Families program, including an income chart, visit healthyfamilies.ca.gov.
We have a quoting system on our website to get you started. That address is www.susanpolk.com. You can visit the website and then call us to get our input, or simply call us directly. Here are the direct lines of our individual sales agents—
Laurie Tonegato Customer Service /Agent – 547-7021
Steve Polk Sales Associate– 544-6230
Susan Polk Broker/Owner – 544-6454